The BEST Moist & Fluffy Vanilla Cupcakes

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

After DOZENS of attempts, I've finally developed the BEST moist & fluffy vanilla cupcakes EVERRR! They're super soft, flavorful, and easy to make. You will never look at another recipe again after trying these!

Vanilla cupcakes arranged on a cake stand with one in the center bitten into

This is actually a somewhat emotional moment for me.

This past year I have DROVEN MYSELF CRAZY over finding the perfect vanilla cake/cupcake recipe. I actually spent my entire spring break on vanilla cake testing- I had 2 days in which I made 8 vanilla cake recipes from the internet, scaled down, all in one day and taste-tested them side-by-side. I then tweaked the best recipes from those, and after a LOT of sampling and sugar, we have arrived HERE!!

These cupcakes are simply flawless. They're moist, they're fluffy, they're soft. I have nothing else to say except YOU NEED TO TRY THEM.

And if you prefer chocolate over vanilla, try my chocolate peanut butter cupcakes and my dark chocolate raspberry cupcakes.

Jump to:

The Magic of the Reverse Creaming Method
Ingredients
Step By Step Instructions
FAQ
What Frosting Should I Use?
Storage and Freezing Instructions
More Cake & Cupcake Recipes You'll Love
The BEST Moist & Fluffy Vanilla Cupcakes

Vanilla cupcakes arranged on a cake stand, with one in the center with the paper liner unwrapped

The Magic of the Reverse Creaming Method

In most cake recipes, you start by creaming the butter and sugar until fluffy. However, with this recipe, you'll start by beating butter into the dry ingredients, then adding the liquid. This is called the reverse creaming method (aka the "paste" method), which was popularized by the baker and cookbook author Rose Levy Beranbaum.

By coating the flour with fat, you minimize the development of gluten, creating more soft and tender cupcakes with a fine, even crumb. Side-by-side, this same recipe made with the creaming method produced cupcakes with a more open, but coarse crumb. The cupcakes with the reverse creaming method were DEFINITELY better, and just as easy to make!

side-by-side comparison of vanilla cupcakes made with the creaming method and reverse creaming method, showing the tops of both cupcakes — Creaming method cupcakes are more flat and squat

side-by-side comparison of vanilla cupcakes made with the creaming method and reverse creaming method, with the cupcakes cut into to see the cross-section of the crumb structure — Reverse creaming method cupcakes have a finer, more even crumb, while the creaming method cupcakes were more coarse (almost like cornbread)

Ingredients

Sugar: Adds sweetness, moisture, and tenderness.
Cake flour: Time and time again in testing I've found that cake flour (a low protein flour) ALWAYS beats all-purpose flour. Side-by-side, this same recipe made with all-purpose flour produced flatter cupcakes with a more dense and coarse crumb. Use bleached cake flour (not unbleached!)- my favorite brand is Swans Down cake flour.
Baking powder & baking soda: A combo of the two creates cupcakes that rise but don't dome and aren't overly pale nor brown.
Butter & oil: Using BOTH butter and oil is KEY for perfect cupcakes! Butter is solid at room temperature while oil is liquid at room temperature. This means oil creates softer, moister cakes and cupcakes. However, you need SOME butter or else vanilla cake will taste bland. I found an equal ratio of the two fats creates the best texture and flavor.
Buttermilk: An acidic dairy product is key for creating moist, tender cupcakes. The next best substitute would be sour cream, but I prefer the flavor and texture you get from buttermilk.
Egg & an egg white: Using all egg whites creates light and airy, but drier cupcakes, while using all whole eggs makes more dense, but moist cupcakes. Using an egg, plus an egg white, is the best compromise: moist AND fluffy!
Vanilla & salt: For flavor.

Step By Step Instructions

STEP 1: Mix the dry ingredients. In the bowl of a stand mixer, mix the sugar, cake flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt.

STEP 2: Add the butter. To the dry ingredients, add the butter and beat on low speed until the mixture forms very fine, sandy crumbs.

Dry ingredients mixed together in a glass stand mixer bowl

Cubes of butter added to the dry ingredients but not mixed in yet

Close-up shot of the dry ingredients with the butter beaten in until fine

The wet ingredients whisked together in a liquid measuring cup

STEP 3: Whisk the wet ingredients. In a separate bowl or liquid measuring cup, whisk the buttermilk, oil, eggs, and vanilla.

STEP 4: Add the wet ingredients to the dry ingredients. With the mixer running on low speed, VERY slowly pour in the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients- if you add the liquid too fast, the batter will be too lumpy. Every 30 seconds or so, stop pouring to let the liquid incorporate. Scrape the bowl every minute or so to make sure everything is evenly mixed.

Thick cake batter with half the liquid incorporated

The finished cake batter in the mixing bowl, thin and light yellow

STEP 5: Pour batter into pan. Line a cupcake pan with 12 paper liners, then pour in the batter about ⅔ to ¾ of the way full. The batter will be thin.

STEP 6: Bake. Bake for 17-21 minutes, or until a toothpick comes out clean or with a few moist crumbs.

STEP 7: Cool and frost. Let the cupcakes cool COMPLETELY to room temperature before frosting, or the frosting will melt. Scroll down for my frosting recipe recommendations!

FAQ

Why are my cupcakes dry?

If your cupcakes are dry, they're likely over-baked or you made an error in the recipe. A few moist crumbs on the toothpick is fine, and don't make any changes to the ingredients or methods (like cutting down on the sugar).

What is the best cupcake liner to use?

I prefer to use parchment paper cupcake liners because they don't get greasy and the cupcakes won't stick. However, any liner you have will work.

What is the best vanilla to use?

I always use vanilla extract, but you can also use an equal amount of vanilla bean paste or even a vanilla bean. However, you won't really notice much of a difference because lots of the flavor goes away while the cupcakes bake. Many bakers preach that using the highest quality vanilla is best, but any vanilla you have is fine.

Vanilla cupcakes on a marble cake stand, with frosting piped on top in a swirl

What Frosting Should I Use?

This goes down to preference! Here's a rundown on some of the different types of frosting.

American buttercream: The classic frosting with butter and powdered sugar. I'm personally not a fan because I think it's overly sweet and chalky-tasting, but it's stiff for decorating.
Cream cheese buttercream: Tangy and less sweet than American buttercream, but still easy.
Swiss meringue buttercream: To make it, you cook egg whites and sugar over a double boiler, then you whip the mixture to stiff peaks and add butter. It's much less sweet and tastes very buttery. It's lighter than American buttercream, but still stable for piping and decorating.
Italian meringue buttercream: Similar to swiss meringue buttercream in terms of taste and texture but it's even more stable, making it great for intricate piping designs and stacking layer cakes. To make it, you add a hot sugar syrup to whipping egg whites, then add butter.
Stabilized whipped cream: The easiest frosting on this list and also the lightest, but doesn't pipe as neatly.

This isn't even ALL the types of frosting you can use... you can also experiment with German buttercream, French buttercream, Russian buttercream, and more... All of these frosting types can even be flavored with lemon, cocoa powder, fruit, etc for more possibilities!

Close-up shot of a vanilla cupcake bitten into

Storage and Freezing Instructions

Store leftover cupcakes in an airtight container and keep them at room temperature for 2-3 days or in the freezer for up to 2-3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator and bring to room temperature before serving.